Food for Thought.

Here's the situation: I have a (unspecified) friend that likes a (unspecified) boy. The boy has a (unspecified) girlfriend and yet she continues to pursue. Despite the fact that she is being a total slore, I have a question for you all: 

Could you ever trust someone that cheated on their partner to be with you? 

Personally I feel like I couldn't trust someone that I know is capable of cheating - even if it was for me. There is no romance in that, people. And for the record, I still think it's skank-tastic to just "wait" until they break up with their significant other. Clearly you are manipulating things, so don't go on thinking it's okay just because you're telling yourself you "won't let anything happen." 

Obviously I still love my friend, and all the skanks out there. I mean no offense to any of you. Well, actually I kind of do. But still, can you just answer my question? Because it is kind of pecking at my brain. I just don't see how you can break up a relationship and then expect that person to treat you any differently. They had a commitment with their partner that they broke, you're new and there is no explicit commitment between the two of you, what makes you think it will be different? 

AGAIN: Could you ever trust someone that cheated on their partner to be with you?

20 comments:

Melissa said...

Nope. Cheating isn't ever acceptable. If you aren't happy in a relationship, don't be in that relationship. Cheating shouldn't ever be an option.

Steph said...

I totally, 100% agree. That's all I have to contribute :)

Michelle said...

No I definitely could not.

Ashley McCardia said...

I completely agree with you samm. a cheater is a cheater is a cheater.

slore needs to respect herself more...because she obviously deserves better and doesn't think so.

Rachel said...

No, I don't think I would ever feel safe or feel like I trusted my guy if I were in that situation. And what's wrong with that girl?? My husband had a girlfriend when I first met him, so to me, he was automatically not even a prospect, he was 'taken.'
obviously that didn't work out, but I would have never thought of pursuing him at that time...and for the record, I didn't even pursue him when he was single, it was all him chasing clueless me. :P

JanM ♥ said...

I just believe that if a relationship started the wrong way (you stole a guy or you cheated on someone), it's going to end because of the same thing. Karma's a B. ;)

xo,
janmloves.blogspot.com
I'm having a giveaway on my blog if you're interested :)

shannon rose said...

not everything is so cut and dry or black and white. i don't pretend to know the details of someone's life or their relationships. and while i'm certainly not endorsing cheating, people need to not be so quick to come down with a ruling on the matter.

-s

Brittany Hendler said...

I completely agree with you! I could never trust the guy plus that would be a complete turn off for me.

Brittany
Secondhandsolace.blogspot.com

Adriana Morales said...

It would be highly difficult to trust someone if they are cheating, but then again everyone deserves a second chance so who am I to judge or say they will or will not repeat the cycle. They should not continue to cheat though, karma is a B.

Audrie Is... said...

Tough one! Going into a marriage in a few short months, I feel an urge to say NO, I never would, but I have also always stuck to the saying that "you never know what two people have unless you are one of them" so it's hard to say viewing from the outside in. In other words, if it doesn't involve me..who cares. To each their own:)

Micah said...

Nope. My theory is this --- if he cheats WITH you, he will cheat ON you.

Emily said...

I think it was Johnny Depp who said “If you fall in love with two people at the same time, choose the second one, because if you really loved the first one, you wouldn't of fallen for the second.” That being said, cheating is never okay, and if the guy wants to stay with the (unspecified) girlfriend, your friend needs to respect herself enough to handle the situation appropriately.

Kelly B. said...

I don't live in a black and white world, but I 100% disagree with the 2 comments that implied that "we don't know their relationship" and what led to the cheating.

Doesn't effing matter.

If your friend is his soul mate he'd end it with that other broad toot suite. and if your friend respected other people, she'd wait for him to do whatever he needed to do (if their relationship WAS on the verge of ending) and then start from there.

I have a friend who actively got one guy to cheat on a known gf, and then dated him for a year and a half. How is that relationship not then tainted? I'd rather start fresh and honest. She then got a 2nd guy to cheat on his gf by conveniently "never asking" if they were still together, and feigning innocence. I have no patience for that kind of shit, and it's a cop out for people to say "to each their own".. and "we don't know them".. cheating is NEVER okay. It's SO easy to NOT cheat and end it.

Breanna said...

Even if some guy had this unrequited desire to be with me and I didn't know it, then they broke up with their girlfriend and said they wanted to be with me (myself knowing none of that history), I would turn them down without even thinking!
If they could do it to their current girlfriend, who's to say they wouldn't do that to me?
By the way - slore is like one of my favorite words. haha.

Anonymous said...

I wish I could tell you the whole truth. But I do love her too much.

Myranda said...

No, what is to stop him from cheating on you. You won't be the "special one".
Myranda
www.prettylivingpdx.com

Kara said...

Once a cheater, always a cheater.

Hugs!
Kara

Kelly { MessyDirtyHair } said...

no i couldn't trust someone who cheated to be with me..or cheated in general. That saying once a cheater always cheater, most of the time is true!

Mrs Independent said...

NOPE. I don't think the addage "once a cheater, always a cheater" is necessarily true, but trust is HUGE in a relationship. I don't want to have to question that. Ever.

Kerri Lynne said...

I don't think that the "once a cheater, always a cheater" thing is true. However, I don't want to be the one you cheated with because I'd never trust you. If you were young and cheated in the past, I feel like you can make mistakes, learn from them and grow. But if you cheated on someone WITH ME, how did you have time to learn your lesson if you just jumped from her bed into mine? No thanks.