A defining moment for America.

Reuters
Last night, like anyone else, I was overjoyed to hear that the last suspect in the Boston bombings had been taken into custody alive and without incident. With the six bombs the suspect had, that final scene could have been a lot more traumatic and I'm thankful it wasn't. Living all the way in Minnesota, I couldn't imagine how relieved those on the East coast, particularly Massachusetts, must have felt. 

I was proud of all the law enforcement involved and even more so proud of the sheer vigilance that many everyday citizens took upon themselves. If I had been in Watertown last night, I would have cheered for the police along with everyone else. Law enforcement in Boston was working hard. They deserved applause.

Then something happened. Even in the absence of law enforcement, news stations started to play the chanting and yelling of people all over the East coast. Dressed in red, white, and blue, people were waving their American flags and chanting "USA! USA! USA!" These were full blown parties happening on the streets, even in NYC. I won't even get into the things happening on social media. It was very similar to when Osama bin Laden was killed. I didn't necessarily agree with that celebration, but I understood it. Having experienced 9/11 and grown up in a post-9/11 world,  my generation has spent majority of our lives hearing about al Qaeda and fearing al Qaeda, especially it's leader  Osama bin Laden. After all, he had proven time and time again the fragility of countries around the world. Knowing he was dead and al Qaeda was decapitated gave me a fleeting sense of peace. 

But what about Dzhokar Tsarnaev, the boy this country has already decided is guilty? 

I trust in our law enforcement. If the FBI says that Dzhokar Tsarnaev and his brother are suspects in the bombings, I trust that they have good reason. That being said, the general public has no proof or evidence that these two men carried out these bombings. All we know is that they were at the Boston Marathon along with thousands of others. I'll say this again: I trust the FBI. But right now I can't say for certain who did what,  because I haven't been shown anything. 

I am thankful he was caught because I value justice. The FBI had reason to call him a suspect so can only imagine they will have plenty of questions to ask him. I have confidence in our judicial system and have faith that should Tsarnaev survive, they will find answers and give  him and those who lost their lives justice. But  even working under the general consensus that he is guilty, I will not celebrate a teenager likely spending the rest of his life in jail, or being given the death penalty, for killing four and injuring almost 200 others. That is not to be celebrated. That is disgusting. That is heartbreaking. 

It's disgusting how quickly this became two men against America. After the Newtown shooting and after the Aurora shooting (both of which killed more people, not that it makes them any more tragic), people were not screaming "AMERICA!" on the streets. People were not repeatedly saying "don't mess with America!" on various social media websites. During and after these events, there was little, if any, talk about America. Yes, the "God Bless America" sentiment was there, but it was said to comfort a country in mourning, not to boast. There were definitely no celebrations. America took ease knowing the perpetrators were no longer a threat, and continued to mourn for those that lost their lives. Then again, those shooters were born and bred Americans and weren't Muslim. 

Is that really the difference? After all, we know of no reason or motivation for the Boston bombings. They have yet to discover any links to larger known terrorist groups, and there are conflicting reports on just how devout they were as Muslims. Even so, regardless of how devout they are to the teachings of Islam, that actually gives us very little indication to their motivations. One can be Muslim and commit heinous acts without the two being connected. The same way that a Christians, like Dennis Rader, can. His religious practices had little, if nothing, to do with the horrible things he did. He was not labeled a Christian extremist that was out for anyone who had different religious beliefs, and I think we owe the same courtesy to others. 

Or maybe it's the fact that these two weren't born in America to American parents. If that's the case, everyone should be just as ashamed. 

I beg  you to be careful not to make this horrible tragedy into two men against America. Let's not give them that much credit and make a mockery of our country. Let's show others that we're better than discrimination and bloodlust.  Let's prove that we're above this, that we can mourn the loss of innocent people with dignity and respect. 

I know this post has already been too long and disorganized, so let's continue the conversation in the comments section, or feel free to email me at [email protected]



9 comments:

The Framed Lady said...

I totally agree. Once I heard that the two suspects were Muslim, my heart sank. I was honestly disappointed that the terrorist act was immediately labeled a religiously driven thing, just because they were Muslim.

Sometimes, people just want to hurt other people, and it has nothing to do with God.

Patton Oswalt actually said some really wonderful things about good always outweighing bad in the world, and how no matter how ugly a scene becomes, you will always have brave hearts running TOWARD the destruction to help out of love and decency. I'd rather we focus on how many people survived, and that hopefully there will be justice. There are as many evil Christians as anyone else. Just because someone's a Muslim doesn't make him a religious extremist. When he makes a bomb and hurts people, that's when he becomes an extremist, regardless of religion.

Thanks for the post!

Kelly B. said...

I have the same sentiments. On one hand I understand the relief. On the other... I find something very unnerving about cheering in the aftermath of so much death and tragedy. It seems to trivialize what happened.

Natalie Best said...

I will message you on le chat :)

Martie @ Spunkyrella said...

Being Austrian and not American I felt like I shouldn´t state my opinion on that matter because it could came across pro-terrorist or even anti-american. I am clearly not and I am happy you took action and spoke from my heart. This first and foremost is a tragedy for the victims and their loved ones and the fact that something so joyous like a marathon quickly transformed and always will stay that way in our heads. Whenever the next marathon is coming along, people will ALWAYS think of Boston and the bombings. I feel this to be the most tragic thing.

I didn´t really follow the social media hype around it but of course I got notice of the heartfelt FB message Patton Oswalt posted. I really hope that we can continue to see the world that way and that fear will never take a hold of us and our lives!

Colette Poferl said...

Very well said. This posting moved me more than you can understand. I love the way you think. All angles, all sides, all emotions with a very clear head, and an open heart.
I love you, bammer.

Mrs Independent said...

I think the difference between Newtown/Aurora and Boston was the amount of community involvement in the apprehension. Being from MA makes me see the whole situation through a different set of eyes. The tight knit feeling and community identity that comes with being from that area isn't something I truly valued until I moved away. I think the revelry that took place Friday night came from two sources - 1. A community celebrating that after a week of fear, they were able to come together with law enforcement and capture "the bad guy" 2. In our post 9-11 world, Americans have been conditioned to hate "terrorists" in any form, for any cause. I think with that indoctrination comes a feeling that we, as Americans, have a duty to fight "evil", hence the "USA" chants.

I'm probably one of the biggest bleeding heart liberals ever (I am from MA after all), and not one to be so much "rah rah 'Merica", but I think in this case, it is important that until we know otherwise, this WAS a case of two guys against America. Maybe not directly through an organized terror cell, but we, as Americans, have come to expect certain "rights". One of these would be the freedom to gather on a beautiful spring day without the threat of being physically injured. When people began to compare the loss of life that day to what other countries experience, I couldn't help but shake my head. I'll be the first to bring up the atrocities that occur overseas, but you can't compare that to what happens on American soil. It would be comparing apples and oranges.

And lastly, as far as evidence? (as you know) I sent out several tweets/FB posts Friday, reminding everyone that being Muslim and Chechnyan is no more synonymous with "terrorist" as being American is with "cowboy". HOWEVER, my evidence is that they shot at the police and then one ran at them with a bomb strapped to his chest. That to me, is enough evidence.

Given the prolific use of social media and broadcasting during the chase, I think the country was able to see how hard law enforcement was working to apprehend the suspect - something unprecedented to my knowledge. Part of the celebration was probably people blowing off steam as well after having a week in fear.

I read a great post by a priest on FB last night. I'm not a religious person by any means, and his post really had noting to do with religion, but resonated with me as a human being. Given my ties to the area, I sat glued to the media like many other people. When the suspect was finally apprehended, my husband turned to me and asked what I'd like to see done to him. My answer? "I don't want anything done TO him". I don't think physically punishing this kid (with the death penalty, vigilante justice, or other means) will teach him any sort of lesson, give any peace to the families affected, or prove anything.

This was long and rambly, but I hope you get my thoughts here :)

Samm said...

My only problem with saying the celebration had to do with the challenge in the apprehension of the suspect is that it makes it seem like it was some sort of sport or theatrics, which it certainly wasn't, and thus shouldn't be celebrated as such. I'm not saying that wasn't why there was celebration, I'm saying I hope it wasn't.

Your second point about Americans being conditioned to hate terrorist I agree with 100%. That's why I think so many people jumped on the bandwagon to label this an act of terrorism and these two people terrorists. It gave them more room to do things like forgo reading him his Miranda Rights. Everyday citizens hear "terrorist" and won't care what does or doesn't happen to them. Thus far (I just woke up, so I haven't checked the news today) they have no reason to believe he has any more information that is urgent regarding public safety. There is no evidence or reason to believe he was a part of a larger terrorist organization. The fact that they are bending the rules to fit this person that was prematurely labeled a terrorist is something we should all be concerned about. I call it premature because in order for something to be terrorism, it has to be both logical and politically motivated. Without knowing motivation, it has neither. As far as we know, he could have just thought blowing something up would be fun to watch. The fact that he was so quickly labeled a terrorist and his rights were so quickly revoked is something that everyone should be concerned about, as you said, there are certain rights every American should expect.

I think your point about two men against America is interesting. Why is this important? From where I'm standing, making the assumption that it's these guys against the country only hinders conversation. How does it help the conversation, making these assumptions?

While I agree that the things that happened (shootout, throwing explosives, etc) are overwhelming, they do not necessarily prove guilt. The same way that the bizarre things Casey Anthony did after she allegedly killed her daughter wasn't enough to convict her guilty of murder. I know that is a much, much, much smaller scale, but it's the same basic idea. One could argue that these guys were scared shitless after the whole country deciding they were responsible for the Boston bombings and had a severe lapse in judgement and/or break from reality. Do I think that's what happened? No. But we can't rule it out quite yet.

I agree with you with just about everything else in your post. And I know you being from MA, you have a totally different perspective, which I respect!!

Andiepants said...

Dearest Samm, I love you. This will also be a super random thoughts type of reply
This really hit home for me too. I run races and this year, my first half-marathon. The fact that a race/event that celebrates joys and accomplishments was disturbed, scared me a bit. Way before there were suspects, I was alarmed. How will races be secured in the future? My friends and I usually feel pretty safe when we run and after the race, the celebrations are packed with people. So now, it will be completely different and yes maybe a little scary. I will still run, because run makes me feel healthy, stress free, and it makes sweat a lot too. HA!
What happened after they were identified and found, just felt a little weird. It felt a little like witches of salem. However, like you, I trust the FBI for having their reasons to look for them. Above all, I trust why they can't publicize all of the reasons as to why they felt they were suspects. It's just hard that some people focus on certain characteristics...like their religion or their nationality or their ethnicity! It's not about that people! So let's not focus on this! Let's come together as a community and help each other out, without pointing fingers at race, ethnicity, nationality, or religion. Let's stop putting this on the news 24/7 because its too much for anyone to handle.
I was not born in the US, however, I consider myself an American. This country was founded by folks from different parts of the world and the US, continues to be a melting pot of many more different nationalities. I'm so proud of everything the country and the Boston community was able to accomplish in the last week. I can see why everyone wanted to go out to celebrate after being scared and locked up at home for a few days. Although there has been a lot of negative focus and horrible losses, we should definitely try to look at the positive outcomes and how well a community has worked to apprehend the suspects.

Much respect for my Boston and MA people and for my runners too!
xoxo

Tiffany @ Polka Dotted Cats said...

Yes, to all of what you said. So much yes. I'm glad you wrote this down and put it on the internet. Someone had to.