Fuck. Welfare.
(I just finished writing this and it's really fucking long. Sorry about that. I went a lot of different places in this one. A little story about me. A little story about Jesus. A little story about why I hate people. You know, the works. )
Every once and a while I sit down at my computer to write a blog post and just think "fuck."
It goes a little something like this: I don't know how to say what I want to say, fuck. I don't know if people will understand my point, fuck. I don't know if this will make people hate me, fuck. I can't articulate my message, fuck. Do I even know what I want to say? Fuck. Do I even think this matters? Fuck. This is going to be long, no one will even read it, fuck.
But I keep going anyways. Because when has not making sense stopped me? When has someone's potential reaction stopped me from writing what I want to write? I don't think ever. Although, I have a bad memory so who really knows.
Anyways. Here I am on a "fuck" kind of day.
Let's talk about welfare, ladies and gentleman. And, when I say welfare, I'm using it pretty generally. This isn't an academic paper and I haven't prepared any research, I'm just writing my thoughts, so there's that.
Just typing the word makes me feel dirty and weird because society has made it such a shit word. Welfare. A lot of people think of single moms, drunks, laziness, pot heads, whores, "illegals", gangsters, or moochers when they think of welfare. Sadly, you're the exception if you think of hard-workers, disabled people, the elderly, children, or people thrown away to the system.
Why are we here? Well, today I had a great, productive conversation with a Republican about welfare. She kept using words like hand outs, lazy, takers, and welfare lifestyle, while referring to Democrats as "those give away Democrats who just want to give everyone whatever they want." She, and a few others that I know, would like to get rid of welfare completely.
Sigh.
People like this make me sad. Really, really, sad. They think that just because they know someone that knew someone that knew someone that "saved up all their welfare" to buy a horse that welfare should be gone away with. They think that because they saw a woman with a "designer" purse and her nails done buying Cheetos with government assistance that the whole system is corrupt. They think this makes them an expert witness to the state of welfare and who deserves it and who doesn't.
What they don't realize is that purse could be fake. Their friend could have done their nails. Maybe they're in beauty school, trying to work their way out of perpetual poverty. And maybe that someone who knows someone who saved their money and bought a horse just doesn't have the whole story straight.
What they don't realize is a lot of welfare recipients are working people, veterans, elderly, or children. What they don't realize is that when they talk about welfare programs draining our resources and taking advantage of "working people's hard earned money" is that the threat here isn't the poor taking advantage of your tax dollars, it's the wealthy. (Not to mention, most of the people receiving government assistance pay into it just like you and I.) It's the people who have the time, money, and knowledge to look over tax laws and find loopholes for themselves and their business. It's the wealthy. (Would you like to talk about corporate welfare? Or should we leave that for another day?)
What they don't realize is the face of welfare isn't actually the welfare queen. At one point, it was a 6 yr old me.
My dad was dying, my mom was in nursing school, my brother and I were children who needed to eat. Period. I wouldn't have had the opportunities I've had in my life if it weren't for government assistance helping my family when we needed it the most and allowing my parents to stay on their feet when everything else was going to shit. My favorite stuffed animal, if I remember correctly, is from a food shelf. And again, my story isn't unique. I'm not in the minority, I'm in the majority. This is welfare, people.
And most people don't expect that of me. Growing up, it was completely normal. I never thought twice about it, even when my family was well off, until I went to Bethel and realized that by their standards, I kind of grew up on the wrong side of the tracks. (I beg to differ, of course. This was by their standards, not mine. I never needed anything I didn't have. My mom never made it feel like we were the least of these. I grew up incredibly blessed with a lot more than a lot of people. Not to mention, I am who I am because of where I came from and I think I'm pretty fucking awesome. But again, for another day.) So people never expected it from me. I remember a friend from high school whose mom was going off about how her children didn't get free lunch because they worked. "Why are we getting punished because we work? It's sickening." She said the same thing about college financial aid, she was a gem of a woman.
As soon as I told her that I got free lunch once upon a time, she shut up. She back tracked. Suddenly there are some people that legitimately needed it. Suddenly she realized that she had the time and money to actually send her children to school with packed lunches, it suddenly made sense that a lot of parents working minimum wage jobs or working the night shift don't have the time to pack lunches for their children, or the money to do it. It was miraculous to witness her sudden apparent change of heart.
See, because you don't know everyone's story. You don't know everyone's finances. It's easy to condemn strangers. It's easy to condemn a group of people you have no personal connection with. It's harder to look someone in the eyes, whose story you know and understand, and tell them that they're wrong, lazy, stupid, or greedy for taking help when they needed it.
Do some people abuse the system? Undoubtedly. But again, I'm not so much worried about people abusing the welfare system as much as I am worried about the wealthy and big corporations abusing the system.
Ugh.
I promised myself I wouldn't let myself bring religion into this, but I have to. My faith system is the foundation for my political ideology. Here's my deal: I believe in helping the least of these. Not everyone has the means to do it themselves. While I don't believe this country was founded on Christian values, that's something conservatives love to spout off on a regular basis, so I'm going to feed into that and say that having a safety net built into our country specifically for the least of these is the most practical and Christ-like practice we have in this country.
And before you say that responsibility should be given to religious institutions, you need to realize that would put something like a two-million dollar a year burden on each individual church in the United States. The financial means aren't there and either are the administrative means or man power to carry out such an operation. Religious institutions simply can't carry that burden. (There's also the argument that churches could then deny assistance to people not affiliated with their religion and/or push their religious agenda.) As you can see, in order to adequately serve the least of these, the government needs to lead the way.
So I don't know how to end this. I don't know what I was exactly trying to say. This was my disorganized rant about welfare. If you've made it this far, congratulations. If not, well, hopefully you're on to better things.
Feel free to tell me what you think, of course.
xo,
samm
10 comments:
Perfectly said Samm. :)
As you know, I'm a republican. I'm also vastly anti-welfare. I won't say there aren't good people who need because there are BUT I no longer believe in or support the system for the following reason:
I had cancer. I lost my job due to my cancer. My unemployment didn't even come close to covering all my financial responsibilities. I had to choose each month between my bills, food, medicines, or medical co-pays. I applied for food stamps. I was denied. Their reasoning? I owned my home and didn't have a child. I was penalized for working hard and being responsible. Faith in system lost - probably forever. I would have starved and lost my home had it not been for my friends and family.
Also, I never see people using their food stamps to buy wholesome nutritious food. Its always pop and junk food. If we did a complete overhaul of the system and put limitations on what they could buy I might be more supportive. And then we have to deal with lovely situations like the one recently in Louisiana where the cards malfunction and all these supposedly good people went on massive spending sprees that they knew they weren't entitled to. You can't tell me the lady with 49 cents on her card actually thought she still had $700 available.
The system is very broken. It failed me.
I love this because it's true. I'm sorry Ashley experienced this. I too know of many people who truly need food stamps and are denied for technicalities. But as a kid who grew up in public housing and food stamps I can tell you that welfare is absolutely necessary so that we don't have kids washing windshields at stoplights like in third world countries. And before anyone says that's a gross exaggeration, just travel off the beaten path in countries like Dominican Republic or Haiti and you'll see what I'm talking about.
It's been awhile since I've really thought much about politics and government. I'm not saying that's a good thing, but I also won't say it's absolutely bad, either. However, when I WAS someone who thought about these sorts of issues, I was that person who [not vocally] believed there were a lot of people who shouldn't be on welfare. You've given me something to think about again. I know nothing of how it works, mostly just stories of its failures, shortcomings, and corruption (minus your story and those of a few others I've been privy to hearing).
I think I may still be wary of many applicants and beneficiaries, and I would hope we could perhaps look into a little better monitoring for those cases that are clearly misusing the system. Not as a punishment, of course. There'd have to be a way to make it clear that the monitoring is not meant to be a means of invading recipients' privacy or punishing them for needing the assistance in the first place (because that's just plain wrong and... "icky"). I just think there need to be more measures taken to convince the population that they should continue paying into the system, aside from the motivator of doing good by their fellow man. That we're being proactive in ensuring that funds are being used properly, to improve people's quality of life as much as it can until they get to a place where they no longer need it.
I'm glad you went ahead and posted this today, despite your brief hesitation in doing so. I needed something to get my neurons and my conscience pumping again.
Absolutely brilliant post.
The need for a welfare system to be in place is something I've always felt strongly about, and you're right too often people use the apparent a use of the few to justify the denial to many. We have a responsibility, not just from a faith standpoint (although that does influence the motivation and desire to help) but a responsibility as a human being to care for our fellow man, to ensure that the basics of life are being met, access to food, shelter, education and healthcare.
Sammi, this pulled at my heartstrings for more than one reason. Thank you.
And....your favorite stuffed animal DID come from someone at the food shelf.
I love you, Mommy
I'm curious, what value system was the country founded on. People on welfare are an easy target. When i was a child, we were on welfare for 2 years. We ate pancakes nightly for days on end and were called welfare rats from the neighbors down the street. We used the system long enough to get back on our feet. The salvation army gave us gifts on Christmas and we bought or clothes second hand. The country did everything in their power to break up our family by removing or father from the picture. They fought hard to make us a dysfunctional group of people. Their ultimate goal was to make us entirely dependent upon them. They would start with my parents and ultimately want the children to grow dependent upon them. It wouldbe looked at as securing future job security for the social services, courts, Family psychologist and last but not least the politicians that would steer funding to all of the above. They would disguise it as help when in reality it was dependency/ enslavement. I despise Corporate handouts which both sides are guilty of But what I despise more is a person telling another person they are a piece of s*** and have no chance of succeeding unless they take the crumbs they have been offered? Americans, are the most generous people in the world And they have always been willing to help the poor, which we should. What people are growing tired of Is a system that allows politicians to use people as political pawns to gain power over them and enslaving them for generations.
This is perfect. I'm a Republican. But I don't think all Democrats are the same. Off the top of my head, I CAN think of 8 couples or families I know that are abusing the system. I think that's why most people are completely rude and assume that's how every Democrat is...which is NOT true. I completely agree with you. I believe there are countless people out there who truly NEED help. I just don't know anybody. Love you Samm!
Love love love this post. And I completely agree that it's the richest people who abuse our systems the most, not the people who are on welfare and truly need help. The loopholes the top earners and corporations find (or pay someone else to find) cost us, as a society, far more than people misusing welfare. I also agree that I strongly believe we should be helping the "least of these" (as you put it). I think it's society's responsibility to help those who need the help. End of story. Thanks for this post :-)
I just love this so much. I am so tired of hearing the same tired argument against Welfare. I don't know when people lost their ability to empathize, but it breaks my heart.
Yes, there are bad people who abuse the system all over the place, it's not just poor people.
I don't have much experience with food stamps, but I do work very closely with government funded child care that is provided to welfare recipients. It makes me sick when I hear my co-workers bad mouthing the parents who are trying to "cheat us out of our money" obviously, I could go on and on about this. But the fact of the matter is, no one story is the same. These people have fallen on hard times and it is not our place to judge that.
Sorry for the rant. I just really love when someone writes something that I can really get behind. Thanks.
Post a Comment